TheCoinHQ

Coin Shops in New York

New York's coin market runs from the dense dealer district in Midtown Manhattan to shops across Brooklyn, Long Island, and upstate. It's a deep market for both bullion and collectible coins, with strong estate and appraisal activity.

Coin Shops189Gold & Silver Buyers145Estate Coin Buyers64Numismatic Appraisers40Rare Coin Dealers2

198 listings in New York

Featured

1Top placement
C
Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry
Coin Shops
Featured

Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry

Coin Shops

Nanuet, NY

5.0(1338)

Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry is a family-owned and operated coin, precious-metals, and jewelry dealer in Nanuet, New York, in business since 1973. The shop buys and sells rare gold and silver coins along with silver, gold, and platinum bullion coins and bars. It also deals in diamonds and fine and estate jewelry, selling gold jewelry by weight and buying unwanted pieces for cash. Loose and mounted diamonds are graded and priced using the Rapaport Diamond Price lists, and the staff includes GIA-trained gemologists. The business offers appraisals and helps customers convert coins, bullion, and jewelry into cash, with larger collections handled by scheduled appointment. Its long history in the same community reflects a focus on both numismatic buyers and jewelry clients. Contact is available by phone or email to arrange a visit or evaluation.

View shop

Enhanced

1Boosted placement
A
A&D Gold & Silver
Gold & Silver Buyers
Enhanced

A&D Gold & Silver

St James, NY

4.8(66)

A&D Gold & Silver is a gold, silver, and coin buyer in Saint James, New York, on Long Island, with more than forty years of experience. The shop purchases gold and silver jewelry, coins, bullion, watches, dental gold, platinum, and palladium, and it handles estate liquidations and large collections. On the selling side it offers collectible coins, gold and silver coins, and fine jewelry. Staff provide free appraisals and immediate cash offers, and the business also does jewelry and watch repairs. Coin evaluation and fine jewelry appraisal are described as core strengths. Walk-in customers are welcome during posted weekday and Sunday hours.

View shop

All listings

196

172 more listings

Buying and selling coins in New York

Two different things get called "selling coins," and they're priced in opposite ways. Bullion — Silver Eagles, gold coins, bars — tracks the live metal price, so the spread between shops is usually small. Collectible coins are priced on date, mint, and grade, where one shop's offer can beat another's by a wide margin.

For anything you think is collectible, get two or three offers before you sell, and ask whether the buyer is an ANA member or an authorized PCGS / NGC dealer — a quick signal they grade to a recognized standard. And don't clean coins: it feels helpful and almost always lowers what a dealer can pay.

Frequently asked questions

How many coin shops are in New York?+

198 coin shops and dealers are listed across New York, rated 4.5★ on average.

Which New York cities have the most coin shops?+

New York (33), Brooklyn (9), and Buffalo (5) have the most listings in New York.

Where can I sell gold or silver in New York?+

Many shops across New York buy gold and silver. Compare offers and confirm the price tracks the current spot price.

Cities in New York

AlbanyNew YorkAuburnNew YorkBathNew YorkBedford HillsNew YorkBellmoreNew YorkBellportNew YorkBohemiaNew YorkBrockportNew YorkBronxNew YorkBrooklynNew YorkBuffaloNew YorkBurkeNew YorkCamdenNew YorkCanandaiguaNew YorkCarmel HamletNew YorkCentereachNew YorkCheektowagaNew YorkChenango ForksNew YorkCiceroNew YorkCommackNew YorkCorningNew YorkDeer ParkNew YorkDepewNew YorkEast IslipNew YorkEast MeadowNew YorkEastportNew YorkElmhurstNew YorkElmiraNew YorkElmsfordNew YorkFarmingvilleNew YorkFloridaNew YorkFlushingNew YorkFreeportNew YorkFrewsburgNew YorkGarden CityNew YorkGreenvaleNew YorkHamburgNew YorkHarrisonNew YorkHartsdaleNew YorkHastings-On-HudsonNew YorkHicksvilleNew YorkHolbrookNew YorkHornellNew YorkHorseheadsNew YorkHuntingtonNew YorkIslipNew YorkIthacaNew YorkJackson HeightsNew York

For Coin Shop Owners

Own or Manage a Coin Shop?

Claim your listing, update your business details, add specialties, and help collectors find your shop more easily.

Claim Your ListingSee Listing Plans