Tarrytown Jewelers
Coin ShopsHartsdale, NY
Coin and metals values change quickly. Tarrytown Jewelers handles coins, appraisals, jewelry, and diamonds in Hartsdale, New York. A simple local option for coins, metals, and related valuables.
Coin Shops in Hartsdale, NY
Hartsdale has 2 coin shops and dealers in our directory, averaging 4.6 stars. Top-rated locally are Coin Exchange (4.6★, 258 reviews) and Tarrytown Jewelers (4.6★, 154 reviews). 1 of the 2 also handle estate or inherited collections — useful if you're settling an estate rather than building one.
2 listings in Hartsdale
Coin Exchange
Coin ShopsHartsdale, NY
Coin Exchange focuses on coins and gold in Hartsdale, New York. Best suited to coins, jewelry, bullion, or estate valuables that need an in-person review.
Selling an inherited collection in Hartsdale, NY
If you've inherited coins, slow down before selling. Have the collection looked at as a whole first — value often hides in a few key pieces, and breaking it up early can cost you.
Separate bullion (priced off the live spot price) from collectible coins (priced off date, mint, and grade), get two offers on anything that looks collectible, and ask for a written appraisal if the collection is sizable. Reputable dealers will explain how they reached a number.
Frequently asked questions
How many coin shops are in Hartsdale?+
2 coin shops are listed in our Hartsdale directory, rated 4.6★ on average.
What's the best-rated coin shop in Hartsdale?+
Among shops with a meaningful number of reviews, Coin Exchange (4.6★, 258 reviews) and Tarrytown Jewelers (4.6★, 154 reviews) rank highest.
Where can I sell gold or silver in Hartsdale?+
Several Hartsdale shops buy gold and silver. Compare at least two offers and confirm the price is tied to the current spot price.
Do Hartsdale coin shops buy estate or inherited collections?+
Yes — 1 of the 2 Hartsdale shops list estate-collection help.
Other cities in New York
For Coin Shop Owners
Own or Manage a Coin Shop?
Claim your listing, update your business details, add specialties, and help collectors find your shop more easily.