TheCoinHQ

Numismatic Appraisers

Our directory lists 428 numismatic appraisers across 46 states, averaging 4.5 stars. California (43), New York (40), and Pennsylvania (29) have the most listed.

428 listings

Featured

4Top placement
P
Pinehurst Coins
Coin Shops
Featured

Pinehurst Coins

Pinehurst, NC

4.9(4301)

Pinehurst Coins is a coin and bullion dealer in Pinehurst, North Carolina, operating since 2004. The shop sells gold, silver, platinum, and palladium in a range of forms, including American Gold and Silver Eagles, Gold Buffalos, commemoratives, international coins, rounds, bars, and bags of junk silver. It also carries rare and collector coins along with hobby supplies and reference books. The business buys coins and collections and describes a defined appraisal process for evaluating what customers bring in, which can help with estate and inherited holdings. Orders can be placed online, with free shipping on purchases above a set amount. Pinehurst Coins is an authorized dealer for PCGS and NGC and lists membership in the Professional Numismatists Guild and the American Numismatic Association. Retail and customer-service hours are posted for weekday visits and phone contact.

Coin ShopsView shop
D
David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin
Coin Shops
Featured

David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin

St. Petersburg, FL

4.9(1757)

David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin is a locally owned jewelry, coin, and precious-metals shop on Central Avenue in St. Petersburg, Florida, serving the area since 1971. The business buys and sells gold, silver, and investment metals along with rare coins and currency, and it handles estate jewelry and collections. On the jewelry side it offers engagement, bridal, and fine jewelry, custom design, and repair and restoration work. Services include appraisals and valuations, estate buying, and coin grading and trading, carried out by a staff that the shop describes as GIA-trained professionals, master jewelers, Registered Master Valuers, and experienced numismatists. Customers can shop in store, browse online, or buy coins and currency through the company eBay store. Weekday hours are posted for walk-in visits. The shop combines fine-jewelry services with coin, currency, and bullion buying and selling under one roof.

Coin ShopsView shop
C
Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry
Coin Shops
Featured

Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry

Nanuet, NY

5.0(1338)

Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry is a family-owned and operated coin, precious-metals, and jewelry dealer in Nanuet, New York, in business since 1973. The shop buys and sells rare gold and silver coins along with silver, gold, and platinum bullion coins and bars. It also deals in diamonds and fine and estate jewelry, selling gold jewelry by weight and buying unwanted pieces for cash. Loose and mounted diamonds are graded and priced using the Rapaport Diamond Price lists, and the staff includes GIA-trained gemologists. The business offers appraisals and helps customers convert coins, bullion, and jewelry into cash, with larger collections handled by scheduled appointment. Its long history in the same community reflects a focus on both numismatic buyers and jewelry clients. Contact is available by phone or email to arrange a visit or evaluation.

Coin ShopsView shop
E
Coin Shops
Featured

Erie Gold Exchange

Erie, PA

4.9(704)

Erie Gold Exchange is a family-owned buyer and seller in Erie, Pennsylvania, in business since 1982 and operating two locations on West 8th Street and Peach Street. The shop buys numismatic and collectible coins, silver coins dated 1970 and older, and gold, silver, and platinum bullion, along with estate jewelry, diamonds, designer pieces, and vintage watches. It also sells precious metals and coins from its inventory. Services include appraisals ranging from a single item to an entire estate, free value estimates, and XRF testing to verify metal purity. Staff evaluate coins, bullion, and collectibles in person, and the Erie Estate Buyers team assists households working through inherited holdings and larger estate lots. Customers can arrange layaway on purchases and have watches serviced in store. The business shares updates through its Facebook and Instagram pages.

Coin ShopsView shop

Enhanced

5Boosted placement
R
Revell Jewelers
Coin Shops
Enhanced

Revell Jewelers

Bettendorf, IA

4.9(787)

Revell Jewelers is a family owned fine jewelry shop in Bettendorf, Iowa, founded in 2001 in Davenport and relocated to its current Bettendorf location in 2007. Founder James Revell trained through a ten year jewelry apprenticeship in England. Along with custom design and repair, the shop buys old gold, wedding sets, sterling silver, loose diamonds, designer watches, and coins from the public. For coin and precious metal sellers, Revell offers a local counter to sell gold, silver, and coins in person. The store keeps regular weekday and Saturday hours and emphasizes old world craftsmanship and personal service.

Coin ShopsView shop
H
Hupp Jewelers
Coin Shops
Enhanced

Hupp Jewelers

Fishers, IN

5.0(1381)

Hupp Jewelers is a family owned jewelry store in Fishers, Indiana, in business since 1967 and currently led by owner and GIA certified gemologist Angela Peterson. In addition to custom design, repair, and restoration, the shop buys jewelry, precious metal, and coins from customers and handles estate and pre-owned pieces. It provides professional appraisals for insurance and valuation purposes. For coin and metal sellers, Hupp offers an in person counter to sell coins along with gold and silver items. The store welcomes walk-ins during regular hours and emphasizes long standing local service and hands on evaluation.

Coin ShopsView shop
A
A&D Gold & Silver
Gold & Silver Buyers
Enhanced

A&D Gold & Silver

St James, NY

4.8(66)

A&D Gold & Silver is a gold, silver, and coin buyer in Saint James, New York, on Long Island, with more than forty years of experience. The shop purchases gold and silver jewelry, coins, bullion, watches, dental gold, platinum, and palladium, and it handles estate liquidations and large collections. On the selling side it offers collectible coins, gold and silver coins, and fine jewelry. Staff provide free appraisals and immediate cash offers, and the business also does jewelry and watch repairs. Coin evaluation and fine jewelry appraisal are described as core strengths. Walk-in customers are welcome during posted weekday and Sunday hours.

Gold & Silver BuyersView shop
A
ATL Gold Buyers
Gold & Silver Buyers
Enhanced

ATL Gold Buyers

Atlanta, GA

4.9(502)

ATL Gold Buyers is a family-owned buyer and seller in Atlanta, Georgia that handles gold, silver, coins, bullion, diamonds, and fine jewelry. The business describes more than 35 years of operation and offers honest appraisals along with professional jewelry and watch repair. Sellers can bring in precious metals and collectible items for evaluation, and the shop also carries fine jewelry, including vintage pieces and items from recognized brands. ATL Gold Buyers lists membership in the Georgia Jewelers Association and Jewelers of America. An online store is also referenced for browsing available jewelry and estate pieces.

Gold & Silver BuyersView shop
A
Rare Coin Dealers
Enhanced

Allouez Rare Coin

Green Bay, WI

4.8(189)

Allouez Rare Coin is a coin shop in Green Bay, Wisconsin, that buys and sells United States and foreign coins, currency, bullion, jewelry, and ancient coins. The store offers gold and silver bullion, purchases sterling silver items and gold jewelry, and provides coin appraisals. Staff take time to grade and price coins objectively and explain condition issues to customers, and reviewers note competitive bullion pricing. The business maintains a Facebook page and an Instagram account rather than a standalone website, and it welcomes walk-in customers to its Webster Avenue location. It serves collectors and sellers looking to buy, sell, or value coins and precious metals.

Rare Coin DealersView shop

All listings

191

167 more listings

How to choose a numismatic appraiser

Look for dealers who are transparent about how they price. For collectible coins that means date, mint, and grade; for bullion it means a clear link to the live spot price.

Membership in the ANA, or authorized-dealer status with PCGS or NGC, is a quick signal of credibility. For anything potentially valuable, get more than one opinion before you buy or sell.

Frequently asked questions

How many numismatic appraisers are listed on TheCoinHQ?+

428 numismatic appraisers across 46 states, rated 4.5★ on average.

What are the best-rated numismatic appraisers?+

Among those with a meaningful number of reviews, USA Pawn Shop I55 South (5★, 3160 reviews) and Hupp Jewelers (5★, 1381 reviews) rank highest.

Numismatic Appraisers by state

California43New York40Pennsylvania29Florida26Texas25New Jersey21North Carolina18Ohio16

Numismatic Appraisers by city

AustinSan AntonioNew YorkMemphisPittsburghChicagoRichmondKnoxville

For Coin Shop Owners

Own or Manage a Coin Shop?

Claim your listing, update your business details, add specialties, and help collectors find your shop more easily.

Claim Your ListingSee Listing Plans