TheCoinHQ

Rare Coin Dealers

Our directory lists 26 rare coin dealers across 13 states, averaging 4.4 stars. Washington (6), Florida (3), and Pennsylvania (3) have the most listed.

26 listings

Featured

5Top placement
C
Collect Lincoln
Featured

Collect Lincoln

Winter Haven, FL

Rating not available

Collect Lincoln is an online dealer in American historical material, deepest in struck medals and political Americana. The stock runs to presidential campaign medals catalogued in DeWitt, Lincoln and Washington medals by Lovett, Paquet and Thomas Elder, so-called dollars and official medals from the Columbian, Pan-American and Panama-Pacific expositions, Civil War tokens, Hard Times tokens, British Conder tokens and 1896 Bryan money. Provenance is a real part of what is offered here. A large share of the certified political medals carry the pedigree of the J. Doyle DeWitt collection, the reference cabinet behind the DeWitt numbering system itself, and several trace to John J. Ford Jr. Signed presidential material appears regularly, authenticated by PSA/DNA or JSA, including Theodore Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Calvin Coolidge and William Henry Harrison. On the coin side the emphasis is certified United States type material graded by PCGS and NGC, from Morgan and Seated Liberty dollars to Walking Liberty halves and Standing Liberty quarters, alongside world gold and silver in Austrian, Canadian, Mexican, British, German and Indian issues. Every piece is photographed exactly as it is, never with a stock image or a reference example, and third party certification is stated on the listing wherever it exists. Each listing gives the condition and, where it is known, the history behind the piece. Where a chain of ownership is incomplete or an attribution is probable rather than certain, the listing says so in those words. Pieces are bought directly on the site and can be returned within 14 days for any reason. Collect Lincoln also buys outright and answers appraisal and valuation questions through the site, and past sales stay online as comparables.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
Altier Rare Coins & Jewelry Buyers
Featured

Altier Rare Coins & Jewelry Buyers

Lighthouse Point, FL

4.9(515)

Altier Rare Coins & Jewelry Buyers is a coin and precious metals buyer in Lighthouse Point, Florida, led by owner Justin Altier. The shop purchases rare United States coins, including type coins, gold and silver coins, and mint and proof sets, along with gold and silver bars and rounds, gold, silver, and diamond jewelry, luxury watches, and paper currency such as Federal Reserve notes, gold certificates, and national bank notes. Verbal appraisals are provided at no charge with no obligation to sell, and accepted items are paid the same day. The business states that it is not a pawnshop, estate buyer, or internet marketing operation, and it holds memberships with the American Numismatic Association, PCGS, NGC, PMG, and CAC. Customers can visit during weekday and Saturday hours or reach the shop by phone and live chat.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
American Rare Coin & Collectibles
Featured

American Rare Coin & Collectibles

Bloomington, MN

4.6(338)

American Rare Coin & Collectibles is a coin dealer in Bloomington, Minnesota, founded in 1985 and located in the same area for more than thirty years. The shop buys rare coins, United States gold coins, silver dollars, gold and silver bullion, platinum, palladium, 90 percent and 40 percent silver coins, scrap gold and silver, currency, sterling silver, and full estate collections. It sells circulated and uncirculated United States gold coins, foreign gold coins, silver dollars, bullion, and United States Mint and proof sets. The team offers free evaluations with no obligation to sell, professional appraisals, and estate liquidation, and it accepts mail-in sales for customers outside the area. Staff bring more than two hundred years of combined numismatic experience, and the business is PCGS, NGC, ANA, and PNG affiliated with BBB accreditation. Walk-in customers are welcome, and appointments are recommended.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry
Featured

American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry

Olympia, WA

4.9(862)

American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry is a coin and precious metals shop in Olympia, Washington, with a second location in Sequim. The business buys and sells rare and commemorative coins, gold coins and bullion, silver, platinum, jewelry, vintage watches, diamonds, stamps, and paper money. Owner Frank Kuhn and his staff bring more than twenty-four years of experience and offer coin grading and authentication for collectors. Free appraisals are available at the store, in a customer's home, or at a bank, and the team assists with estate sales and complex collections. The shop is an NGC authorized dealer, described as one of three in Thurston County, and is also PMG and CAC affiliated, with BBB accreditation. Walk-in customers are welcome during store hours, and appointments are preferred for large collections so staff can give them proper attention.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
Featured

Austin Rare Coins and Bullion

Austin, TX

4.7(86)

Austin Rare Coins and Bullion is a rare coin and bullion dealer in Austin, Texas, founded in 1989. The company buys and sells gold, silver, rare coins, ancient coins, world coins, and bullion, and it describes its focus as private gold and silver bullion and certified rare coins. Customers can order online with shipping available nationwide or meet with an advisor in person by appointment. The company also assists with estates and provides appraisals, and it reports more than a billion dollars in gold, silver, and rare coin transactions since its founding. Coins are handled through NGC and PCGS certification, and the business is BBB accredited with an A+ rating. Most advisors are described as having over twenty years of industry experience, and the company maintains a presence on Instagram, YouTube, X, and TikTok.

Rare Coin DealersView shop

Enhanced

5Boosted placement
B
BADER RARE COINS LLC
Enhanced

BADER RARE COINS LLC

Quakertown, PA

4.7(62)

Bader Rare Coins is a rare coin dealer in Quakertown, Pennsylvania, that buys and sells rare and unique coins from around the world. The shop also trades gold and silver bullion and buys jewelry, and it offers in-person consultations at its showroom on South West End Boulevard. Customers can visit during posted daytime hours or schedule an appointment by phone. The business focuses on collector coins as well as investment metals, giving both collectors and sellers a place to buy, sell, and trade. Walk-in visitors are welcome, and staff work directly with customers to review coins and precious metals in person.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
Enhanced

Alaska Rare Coins

Fairbanks, AK

4.7(69)

Alaska Rare Coins is a coin and bullion dealer in Fairbanks, Alaska, that has operated since 1976. The shop trades in gold and silver bullion, rare United States coins, world currency, and junk silver, along with Alaska tokens, medals, gold nugget jewelry, and ivory carvings. It stocks United States Mint and Canadian Mint products, South African Krugerrands, and silver bars. Since 1980 the business has conducted numismatic auctions that bring buyers and sellers together, and it holds auctions twice a year. Staff also provide estate appraisals and purchase collections. Alaska Rare Coins is a PCGS authorized dealer serving collectors across the interior of the state.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
Enhanced

Allouez Rare Coin

Green Bay, WI

4.8(189)

Allouez Rare Coin is a coin shop in Green Bay, Wisconsin, that buys and sells United States and foreign coins, currency, bullion, jewelry, and ancient coins. The store offers gold and silver bullion, purchases sterling silver items and gold jewelry, and provides coin appraisals. Staff take time to grade and price coins objectively and explain condition issues to customers, and reviewers note competitive bullion pricing. The business maintains a Facebook page and an Instagram account rather than a standalone website, and it welcomes walk-in customers to its Webster Avenue location. It serves collectors and sellers looking to buy, sell, or value coins and precious metals.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
Enhanced

Ashmore Rare Coins and Metals

Greensboro, NC

4.7(129)

Ashmore Rare Coins and Metals is a full-service rare coin dealer in Greensboro, North Carolina, established in 1987. The firm buys and sells rare coins worldwide and is a major buyer of estates, purchasing gold, silver, and platinum scrap jewelry along with diamonds and gems. President Ash Harrison is described as one of the country's leading Morgan dollar specialists and a past president of the Society of Silver Dollar Collectors. The company is among the larger scrap jewelry buyers in North Carolina and emphasizes educating customers so they can make informed decisions when selling. It holds an A plus rating with the Better Business Bureau.

Rare Coin DealersView shop
A
Enhanced

Americana Rare Coin, Inc.

Sacramento, CA

4.6(110)

Americana Rare Coin is a rare coin shop in Sacramento, California, located on Arden Way near Fulton Avenue. The store specializes in rare United States coins and certified numismatic material graded by PCGS, NGC, CAC, and ANACS, ranging from half cents through double eagles. Inventory includes Morgan and Peace dollars, gold coins, California fractional gold, classic commemoratives, world and ancient coins, currency, and error coins, along with premium bullion and coin supplies. The shop pays for silver dollars, gold, and numismatic items and offers free in-person appraisals, noting that condition must be viewed rather than quoted by phone. It is a PCGS, NGC, and CAC authorized dealer and an ANA life member.

Rare Coin DealersView shop

All listings

16

Rare Coin Dealers at a glance

26 rare coin dealers, 25 of them rated across 4,743 Google reviews, averaging 4.4★.

1 submit to PCGS, NGC, or CAC for customers, 9 handle estate and inherited collections, and 14 offer appraisals.

Most common specialties: Rare U.S. coins (25), U.S. coins (18), and Gold coins (16).

Collectible pricing turns on date, mint, and grade rather than weight, so two offers on the same coin can differ by a lot more than they would on bullion.

Frequently asked questions

How many rare coin dealers are listed on TheCoinHQ?+

26 rare coin dealers across 13 states, rated 4.4★ on average.

What are the best-rated rare coin dealers?+

Among those with a meaningful number of reviews, ASB Rare Coins, LLC (5★, 27 reviews) and American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry (4.9★, 862 reviews) rank highest.

Rare Coin Dealers by state

Washington6Florida3Pennsylvania3Texas2Wisconsin2California2New York2Minnesota1

Rare Coin Dealers by city

AppletonFairbanksReadingGreen BayLighthouse PointBeaumontBloomingtonNaples

For Coin Shop Owners

Own or Manage a Coin Shop?

Claim your listing, update your business details, add specialties, and help collectors find your shop more easily.

Claim Your ListingSee Listing Plans