TheCoinHQ
Green Bay, WI

Coin Shops in Green Bay, WI

Green Bay has 4 coin shops and dealers in our directory, averaging 4.6 stars. Top-rated locally are Allouez Rare Coin (4.8★, 189 reviews) and Card & Coin (4.7★, 101 reviews).

Gold & Silver Buyers3Coin Shops2Estate Coin Buyers1Rare Coin Dealers1Numismatic Appraisers1

4 listings in Green Bay

Enhanced

2Boosted placement
A
American Antiques and Jewelry
Enhanced

American Antiques and Jewelry

Green Bay, WI

4.6(950)

American Antiques and Jewelry is a family-owned shop in Green Bay, Wisconsin that has operated since 1989. The store deals in vintage, sterling, gold, and platinum jewelry along with coins, antiques, collectibles, and watches. Buyers can browse a range of unique items, and sellers can bring in coins, jewelry, and collectible pieces. The business highlights offering items at a fraction of prices found in traditional stores and runs regular live product showcases online. With more than three decades in business, the shop serves collectors looking for coins and antiques as well as customers wanting to sell gold and silver items.

Gold & Silver BuyersView shop
A
Enhanced

Allouez Rare Coin

Green Bay, WI

4.8(189)

Allouez Rare Coin is a coin shop in Green Bay, Wisconsin, that buys and sells United States and foreign coins, currency, bullion, jewelry, and ancient coins. The store offers gold and silver bullion, purchases sterling silver items and gold jewelry, and provides coin appraisals. Staff take time to grade and price coins objectively and explain condition issues to customers, and reviewers note competitive bullion pricing. The business maintains a Facebook page and an Instagram account rather than a standalone website, and it welcomes walk-in customers to its Webster Avenue location. It serves collectors and sellers looking to buy, sell, or value coins and precious metals.

Rare Coin DealersView shop

All listings

2

Buying and selling coins in Green Bay, WI

Two different things get called "selling coins," and they're priced in opposite ways. Bullion — Silver Eagles, gold coins, bars — tracks the live metal price, so the spread between shops is usually small. Collectible coins are priced on date, mint, and grade, where one shop's offer can beat another's by a wide margin.

For anything you think is collectible, get two or three offers before you sell, and ask whether the buyer is an ANA member or an authorized PCGS / NGC dealer — a quick signal they grade to a recognized standard. And don't clean coins: it feels helpful and almost always lowers what a dealer can pay.

Frequently asked questions

How many coin shops are in Green Bay?+

4 coin shops are listed in our Green Bay directory, rated 4.6★ on average.

What's the best-rated coin shop in Green Bay?+

Among shops with a meaningful number of reviews, Allouez Rare Coin (4.8★, 189 reviews) and Card & Coin (4.7★, 101 reviews) rank highest.

Where can I sell gold or silver in Green Bay?+

Several Green Bay shops buy gold and silver. Compare at least two offers and confirm the price is tied to the current spot price.

Other cities in Wisconsin

AppletonBeloitBrookfieldCedarburgCrivitzEau ClaireFond du LacGraftonHales CornersHudsonJanesvilleJeffersonKenoshaKimberlyLa CrosseLake GenevaMadisonMaustonMequonMiddletonMilwaukeeMononaMt HorebNew Berlin

For Coin Shop Owners

Own or Manage a Coin Shop?

Claim your listing, update your business details, add specialties, and help collectors find your shop more easily.

Claim Your ListingSee Listing Plans